The resisting charge stuck until the DA’s office received an audio file just this Thursday, in which you can clearly hear the arresting Denver Police officer say she did not resist.
“She pulled away,” the officer is heard saying. “She didn't strike us. We're not charging her with assault, or resisting arrest or anything like that. But, it was pretty hard to get the handcuffs on her."
What happened last fall at Northfield High School is only now becoming clear. The principal, Avi Tropper, was allowed to resign. The school resource officer was terminated.
The whole ordeal started when Tropper pulled Mills out of class.
“I was wearing a purple bandanna,” Mills said.
She said she asked why she couldn’t wear it, as she had worn the bandanna in school dozens of times before. She then asked if she could go to the bathroom.
"And they said, 'You know -- we will follow you in there.' And I said, 'You cannot do that. That's not OK.'"
She said she walked in and went to the furthest stall in the back. “And they came in the bathroom and the security guard unlocked the stall,” Mills said.
After that -- by all accounts =- it gets ugly.
“He grabbed my right arm and pinned it behind my back,” Mills said. “At that time, I became very scared and I did not know what to do."
Things calmed down, but only after a female staffer intervened.
“I was in tears,” Mills said. “I was in hysterics. I did not know what to do. She blocked both of them from coming anywhere near me."
The DA said Thursday he was sorry for the trauma the experience caused Mills, but added that sometimes evidence doesn’t present itself until late in the case.
"Upon learning of that evidence today, our ethical obligation is very clear to dismiss this case," said Lynn Kimbrough, communications director for the Denver DA’s office. "We wish this young woman the very best, and hope that she can move forward."
"We don't believe that. If they wished her the best, they would have left her alone in the first place," said Olisa Tolokun-Ajinaku. “Two grown, white men follow Shani into the bathroom. If Shani were a white girl and this had been two black men, we already know that they would have been arrested immediately. Avi Tropper still has not been arrested. Nathan Montgomery still has not been arrested.”
Mills’ family says the principal and security guard should face criminal charges.
"Backhanded justice is not justice,” said Lucero-Mills. “It doesn't stop here. It can start here, though."
The family is now calling on the Chief of Police to step in and file criminal charges against the now former principal and school security guard.
The group Black Lives Matter 5280 is also putting pressure on the Denver Police Department.
After the arrest, Mills was put on pre-trial home detention. Something her family said had a traumatic impact on the teenager.
“It’s not my job to do what Mitch Morrissey's office should be doing,” said Lucero-Mills. “How this ever went on for this long is absurd. Evidently, someone did not do their job.”
The family called it a smear campaign.
“We filed a complaint with the DPD months ago. Yet, they’re still pursuing Shani. Hunting Shani. Targeting Shani,” said Tolokun-Ajinaku.