Gay Teen Murder Charges Upgraded
DA Finds Evidence Of Robbery In Slaying Of Cortez Navajo
POSTED: 6:15 a.m. MDT August 14, 2001
UPDATED: 6:29 a.m. MDT August 14, 2001
CORTEZ, Colo. -- The charge against a New Mexico man accused
of killing a 16-year-old transgender Navajo teen was upgraded to
first-degree murder because of evidence that a robbery was involved, the
prosecutor said.
But Montezuma County District Attorney Joe Olt declined Monday
to call the bludgeoning death of Fred C. Martinez Jr. a hate crime.
Shaun Murphy, 18 (pictured, left), a Farmington, N.M., oilfield worker, was
originally charged with second-degree murder.
Martinez (pictured, right) has been described as being "two-spirited," the
Navajo way of saying he had elements of both male and female
genders. His family and friends say the transgender youth was
comfortable with his identity.
Martinez' death has received a lot of attention from local and
national gay-rights groups, which say it appears he was killed
because he was transgender.
Olt, though, said he wasn't saying the crime was premeditated or
hate-motivated. He said he upgraded the charge to first-degree
murder because the crime allegedly occurred in conjunction with
robbery, another felony offense.
The crime carries a possible death penalty or life prison
sentence.
Martinez' mother, Pauline Mitchell, called the charge of
first-degree murder more appropriate. She said in a statement she
hopes "this takes us a step closer to justice for the death of my
son."
Martinez' bludgeoned body was found June 21 near Cortez. Olt
said the police investigation turned up evidence that Martinez was
robbed before or after his skull was fractured with a blunt object.
Olt has never prosecuted a murder case. He is consulting with
the state attorney general's office and other prosecutors about the
case.
"We care very much about this case. We allege that Martinez was
brutally murdered," Olt said.
Murphy's preliminary hearing was scheduled for Sept. 7.
Shaun Murphy, 18 (pictured, left), a Farmington, N.M., oilfield worker, was
originally charged with second-degree murder.
Martinez (pictured, right) has been described as being "two-spirited," the
Navajo way of saying he had elements of both male and female
genders. His family and friends say the transgender youth was
comfortable with his identity.
Martinez' death has received a lot of attention from local and
national gay-rights groups, which say it appears he was killed
because he was transgender.
Olt, though, said he wasn't saying the crime was premeditated or
hate-motivated. He said he upgraded the charge to first-degree
murder because the crime allegedly occurred in conjunction with
robbery, another felony offense.
The crime carries a possible death penalty or life prison
sentence.
Martinez' mother, Pauline Mitchell, called the charge of
first-degree murder more appropriate. She said in a statement she
hopes "this takes us a step closer to justice for the death of my
son."
Martinez' bludgeoned body was found June 21 near Cortez. Olt
said the police investigation turned up evidence that Martinez was
robbed before or after his skull was fractured with a blunt object.
Olt has never prosecuted a murder case. He is consulting with
the state attorney general's office and other prosecutors about the
case.
"We care very much about this case. We allege that Martinez was
brutally murdered," Olt said.
Murphy's preliminary hearing was scheduled for Sept. 7.
Previous Stories:
- July 26, 2001: Gay Teen Autopsy Non Conclusive
- July 22, 2001: Beating Death Brings Gay American Indians Together
- July 11, 2001: Cortez Murder Suspect Lived With Murderer
- July 6, 2001: Arrest Made In Gay Teen Murder
Copyright 2002 by TheDenverChannel.com. The Associated Press contributed to this report. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.





