Vail Ordered To Give 911 Tapes To Kobe's Defense Team
Calls Made From Accuser's Home Will Not Be Released Publicly
POSTED: 6:36 am MDT September 30, 2003
UPDATED: 7:47 am MDT September 30, 2003
EAGLE, Colo. -- In a victory for Kobe Bryant's attorneys, a judge on Monday ordered Vail police to turn over records of 911 calls made from the home of the woman who has accused the NBA superstar of rape.
The Vail Police Department, which handles emergency calls for Eagle County authorities, had asked Gannett to throw out a defense subpoena for the records, saying releasing them would violate an order from another judge.Gannett said he was not bound by state District Judge Richard Hart's decision rejecting a newspaper's request to see the 911 records. It is unknown exactly when the calls were made but it is believed that they were made before the alleged assault, 7NEWS reported.Friends of the alleged victim say she has twice overdosed on sleeping pills -- once in her dorm room at the University of Northern Colorado in February and once in May at her home in Eagle.The 911 tapes to be released to Bryant's lawyers are believed to be the calls made by the victim's parents when they found her in her bedroom in May.According to her friends, the 19-year-old was going through an extremely difficult period in her life at the time of the overdose. She returned home from her freshman year of college to find out her ex-boyfriend was dating another woman. Also, around the time of the overdose, a close friend died in an accident while returning from high school graduation ceremonies.The defense has sought the medical records of Bryant's accuser, leading to speculation that they will try to make her emotional stability an issue if the case goes to trial. The woman was treated at a Greeley hospital earlier this year for an unspecified mental health issue.Gannett also said he will decide all unsettled legal questions -- including whether Bryant's 19-year-old accuser will testify at the Oct. 9 preliminary hearing and whether her medical records will be released -- on Thursday to give attorneys time to appeal."It's just a matter of trying to sit down and integrate it all into one response," Gannett said. "They're all related."Bryant, 25, was charged with felony sexual assault after the 19-year-old woman said he raped her June 30 at the exclusive mountain resort where she worked and he was a guest. The Los Angeles Lakers guard, who is free on $25,000 bond, has said the two had consensual sex. The preliminary hearing will determine whether Bryant will stand trial.The defense again asked Gannett to keep the public out of the courtroom during the hearing, saying Bryant rights override the public's right to know."This is an extraordinary case with unprecedented risk that Mr. Bryant will be deprived of his right to a fair trial," defense attorneys Hal Haddon and Pamela Mackey wrote.The attorneys argued that Colorado's Legislature has set a low threshold for closing preliminary hearings in felony sexual assault cases, but that judges have full discretion on such decisions. Prosecutors say there are sufficient safeguards in place so potential jurors will not get enough information to form opinions.If the preliminary hearing is opened to the public, and if it appears as if the case will go to trial anyway, Bryant's attorneys may waive the Oct. 9 hearing to avoid a media circus and prevent the contamination of a potential jury pool, legal analysts say.There were several other developments, including a filing by prosecutors seeking to keep many court records in the case sealed. Prosecutors said media organizations lacked grounds to file the appeal.Gannett also said there is a possibility the hearing would have to be postponed but that he hoped to avoid that.Attorneys for Bryant and for media organizations met with the judge to discuss his order restricting media activities, including punishing organizations that publish the woman's name or photograph. Media attorneys contend parts of the order are unconstitutional.Gannett said he hoped to have changes worked out by Wednesday and that he would schedule a hearing if there are disagreements.
Previous Stories:
- September 29, 2003: Judge In Bryant Case To Make Critical Decisions This Week
- September 29, 2003: Lakers Coach In Eagle, Same Night As Kobe
- September 25, 2003: Kobe's Accuser Wants Crisis Records Kept Private
- September 23, 2003: Eagle DA Asks Judge To Keep Kobe Bryant Hearing Open
- September 22, 2003: Man Charged With Solicitation To Murder Bryant's Accuser
- September 22, 2003: Judge In Bryant Case Weighing Key Decisions As Preliminary Hearing Nears
- September 19, 2003: Bizarre Twist in Kobe Bryant Case, $3-Millon Murder for Hire Plot
- September 19, 2003: Sheriff Cleared In Bryant Leaks Investigation
- September 19, 2003: Ruling Could Hamper Bryant's Defense Efforts
- September 16, 2003: Legal Web Site Publishes Bryant Accuser's Name, Address
- September 15, 2003: Kobe Bryant's Lawyers Press For Accuser's Medical Records
- September 12, 2003: Kobe Bryant Attorneys Want Closed Hearing
- September 10, 2003: New Details In Kobe Bryant Case Released
- September 9, 2003: Attorneys Want Kobe's Accuser To Testify At Prelim
- September 8, 2003: Judge In Bryant Case Won't Permit Courtroom Cameras
- September 5, 2003: Kobe's Lawyers Seeking More Of Accuser's Medical Records
- September 3, 2003: Handful Of Records In Kobe Bryant Case Released
- September 2, 2003: Bryant's Attorneys Ask For Accuser's Medical Records
- September 2, 2003: Probe Of Bryant Leaks Looks Into Court Workers, Prosecutors
- August 30, 2003: Race Coloring People's View Of Bryant's Case
- August 29, 2003: Judge's Ruling On Sealed Records In Bryant Case To Be Appealed
- August 28, 2003: Prosecutors Won't Oppose Records Release In Bryant Rape Case
- August 26, 2003: Bryant's Accuser Not Returning To UNC; Prosecutor Opposes Courtroom Cameras
- August 23, 2003: Bryant Attorney Denies Settlement Rumors
- August 22, 2003: Deal May Be In Works In Kobe Case
- August 22, 2003: Death Threat Against Bryant's Accuser Results In Arrest
- August 20, 2003: Kobe Bryant Court Records Could Be Opened Soon
- August 19, 2003: Public Sounds Off On Kobe Bryant Case
- August 19, 2003: Eagle County Residents Polled About Kobe Case
- August 15, 2003: Judge With Little Experience Could Get Bryant Case
- August 12, 2003: Racist Fliers Found On Eagle County Doors
- August 6, 2003: Bryant Hearing Set For Oct. 9
- August 5, 2003: Cuban Chastised By NBA Commissioner For Kobe Comments
- August 5, 2003: Eagle Prepares For Kobe Bryant Media Onslaught
- August 5, 2003: Since Charges, Bryant On Losing Streak
- August 4, 2003: Kobe Accuser's Alleged Problems May Not Be Considered
- August 4, 2003: Judge Nixes Bryant's Request To Bar Cameras
- August 3, 2003: Kobe Bryant Gets Teen Award
- August 1, 2003: Report: Investigator In Bryant Case Named In Racial Profiling Lawsuit
- July 31, 2003: Judge Rejects Kobe Request Not To Attend Hearing
- July 30, 2003: Report: Bryant Deceived Investigators About Alleged Rape
- July 30, 2003: Woman Pictured As Kobe's Accuser Speaks Out
- July 29, 2003: Court Web Site To Devote Page To Kobe's Case
- July 28, 2003: Will 911 Call From Kobe's Accuser Be Released?
- July 27, 2003: Bryant Prosecutor Getting Threats
- July 26, 2003: Cameras Allowed In Courtroom For Kobe Bryant Hearing
- July 25, 2003: Tabloid Publishes Purported Photo Of Bryant Accuser
- July 25, 2003: Scrutiny Of Kobe Bryant's Accuser Intensifies
- July 25, 2003: Bryant's Accuser Previously Called 'Danger To Self'
- July 24, 2003: Family Of Woman Pictured In Kobe Bryant Case Hires Lawyer
- July 24, 2003: Kobe's Defense Team Familiar With High Profile Cases
- July 24, 2003: Radio Host Reveals Name Of Bryant Accuser
- July 23, 2003: Friend Says Kobe's Accuser 'Felt Chemistry' With NBA Star
- July 22, 2003: Eagle Teen Offered $12,500 For Kobe Bryant Story
- July 21, 2003: Report: Kobe's Accuser Had Recent Overdose
- July 18, 2003: Kobe Bryant Maintains Innocence After Charges
- July 18, 2003: DA To Announce Kobe Bryant Decision This Afternoon
- July 17, 2003: Decision In Kobe Bryant Case To Be Announced Friday
- July 15, 2003: State Crime Lab Working On Kobe Bryant Case
- July 14, 2003: Bryant Tells Paper He's Innocent
- July 14, 2003: Friends Of Kobe Bryant Accuser Go On National TV
- July 12, 2003: Kobe Bryant's Accuser Had Tried Out For 'American Idol'
- July 10, 2003: Prosecutors: Decision In Bryant Case Won't Come This Week
- July 9, 2003: Sheriff Concerned About Pressure On Kobe Bryant's Accuser
- July 9, 2003: Taxi Driver Says NBA Star Was At Hospital After Assault Claim
- July 7, 2003: D.A.: No Decision On Charges Against NBA's Bryant
- July 7, 2003: Kobe Bryant Arrested For Alleged Sexual Assault
Copyright 2004 by TheDenverChannel.com. The Associated Press contributed to this report. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.






