Internal Review Cites AFA Culture For Alleged Sex Assaults
Working Group Found No Cover-Up By Academy Leaders
POSTED: 9:33 am MDT June 19,
2003
UPDATED: 8:46 am MDT June 27,
2003
DENVER -- The Air Force's internal report on allegations of sexual assaults at the Air Force Academy was released on Thursday, and it found no cover-up by academy leaders and no systematic acceptance of assault or institutional avoidance of responsibility. However, it did fault the culture of the academy as the reason why female cadets still fear retaliation for reporting attacks.
The working group that completed the report was formed in February by Air Force Secretary James G. Roche after 7NEWS Investigates uncovered a system at the academy that punished women who had come forward to report sexual assault or rape. In some cases the victims told 7NEWS that they were even drummed out of the prestigious school. After 7NEWS aired the reports, the Air Force changed the whole process, vowing to no longer investigate victims and insuring that the victims and witnesses will be given amnesty from lesser, minor infractions.
However, in Thursday's report, the hand-picked Air Force Working Group for U.S. Air Force Academy Sexual Misconduct said there was no "systematic acceptance of sexual assault at the academy, institutional avoidance of responsibility, or systematic maltreatment of cadets who report sexual assault."It said that all but one of 43 cases of assault investigated between Jan. 1, 1993, and Dec. 31, 2002, were handled within the reasonable discretion of commanders.The report goes on to say that there is a problem with the "culture at the academy that produced a less than optimal environment to deter and respond to sexual assault or bring assailants to justice."It documents problems ranging from confusion among top officers about who was overseeing assaults and cites a "blurred" definition of sexual assault.Even though the leadership of the academy has been removed, no one is being held accountable in this report, 7NEWS Investigative Reporter John Ferrugia said. Even though by changing the whole system for dealing with sexual assault and rape the Air Force admitted to a serious problem, the report said there was no targeting of victims and blamed cadet use of alcohol for 40 percent of the sexual assault cases it reviewed.
However, it did call for more changes at the Academy, including changing the hierarchy system that gives upperclassmen power over freshman cadets.The working group looked at 142 reported assaults at the academy. Eighty-one reports were anonymous and could not be investigated. Of the 61 remaining cases, about half involved enough evidence for prosecution, said Rep. Heather Wilson, R-N.M., a graduate of the Air Force Academy who discussed aspects of the findings with the Associated Press.But how many cadets were interviewed? What the report doesn't say is that most victims, including most current cadets, refused to talk to members of the working group for fear of retaliation, 7NEWS reported.In short, victims of sexual assault at the academy simply didn't trust the Air Force to investigate itself, Ferrugia said.However, many victims did speak with the Department of Defense's Inspector General, which is one of three remaining investigations into sexual assaults at the academy. That report should be completed by late summer.The Air Force Inspector General is also conducting an inquiry and Congress has also created its own panel to investigate and determine if academy commanders should be held responsible.
For example, despite programs in place to address the issues of sexual assault, over the years the problems persisted and commanders apparently didn't take them seriously, 7NEWS reported. And Thursday's report didn't blame any commanders."I think there is an attempt to sort of exonerate themselves from some of the charges they have had to face. The fact is they have a problem there. We all recognize they have a problem including the people in charge at the Pentagon know we have a problem there," Allard told 7NEWS. "(The victims) have lost confidence in the system at the Air Force Academy. I think the challenge is they have to restore confidence in the academy for victims of sexual assault or rape.""Our report's charter was not to assess blame or responsibility but was to evaluate policies, programs and practices in light of the cadet complaints to see if changes needed to be made," said Mary Walker, who headed the working group at the Pentagon. "But there is enough information in there for the secretary and the chief, as commanders, to review whether command had information that perhaps it should have taken action on, and that would be for them to review."At the academy, officials weren't surprised by the outcome of the report, and they have spent the last several months implementing some of the suggestions outlined by the general counsel.At a press conference following the report's release Brig. Gen. Johnny Weida, the academy's interim superintendent, said that he and the academy were looking forward and not backward. He did not want to dwell on the sexual assault allegations, but rather talked about what the school is doing to fix the problem.Weida said it was a cultural issue that cannot be solved quickly by speeches or written guidance, rather it will take some time and some everyday work."Organizations that acknowledge their shortcomings, they fix them and then press on, no matter what area you're talking about. Mediocre organizations ignore the problems, make excuses for their problems and they never get better," Weida said.
| Video |
However, it did call for more changes at the Academy, including changing the hierarchy system that gives upperclassmen power over freshman cadets.The working group looked at 142 reported assaults at the academy. Eighty-one reports were anonymous and could not be investigated. Of the 61 remaining cases, about half involved enough evidence for prosecution, said Rep. Heather Wilson, R-N.M., a graduate of the Air Force Academy who discussed aspects of the findings with the Associated Press.But how many cadets were interviewed? What the report doesn't say is that most victims, including most current cadets, refused to talk to members of the working group for fear of retaliation, 7NEWS reported.In short, victims of sexual assault at the academy simply didn't trust the Air Force to investigate itself, Ferrugia said.However, many victims did speak with the Department of Defense's Inspector General, which is one of three remaining investigations into sexual assaults at the academy. That report should be completed by late summer.The Air Force Inspector General is also conducting an inquiry and Congress has also created its own panel to investigate and determine if academy commanders should be held responsible.Reaction To Report
Sen. Wayne Allard said the new report on the sex assault scandal at the Air Force Academy is incomplete. Allard said that although the report contains some good recommendations, it failed to lay out why and how the problems occurred in the first place.
For example, despite programs in place to address the issues of sexual assault, over the years the problems persisted and commanders apparently didn't take them seriously, 7NEWS reported. And Thursday's report didn't blame any commanders."I think there is an attempt to sort of exonerate themselves from some of the charges they have had to face. The fact is they have a problem there. We all recognize they have a problem including the people in charge at the Pentagon know we have a problem there," Allard told 7NEWS. "(The victims) have lost confidence in the system at the Air Force Academy. I think the challenge is they have to restore confidence in the academy for victims of sexual assault or rape.""Our report's charter was not to assess blame or responsibility but was to evaluate policies, programs and practices in light of the cadet complaints to see if changes needed to be made," said Mary Walker, who headed the working group at the Pentagon. "But there is enough information in there for the secretary and the chief, as commanders, to review whether command had information that perhaps it should have taken action on, and that would be for them to review."At the academy, officials weren't surprised by the outcome of the report, and they have spent the last several months implementing some of the suggestions outlined by the general counsel.At a press conference following the report's release Brig. Gen. Johnny Weida, the academy's interim superintendent, said that he and the academy were looking forward and not backward. He did not want to dwell on the sexual assault allegations, but rather talked about what the school is doing to fix the problem.Weida said it was a cultural issue that cannot be solved quickly by speeches or written guidance, rather it will take some time and some everyday work."Organizations that acknowledge their shortcomings, they fix them and then press on, no matter what area you're talking about. Mediocre organizations ignore the problems, make excuses for their problems and they never get better," Weida said. Previous Stories:
- June 19, 2003: AFA Panel Member Resigns Over Doubts About Rape Allegations
- June 18, 2003: Review Panel's Report On Assaults At AFA To Be Released Thursday
- June 6, 2003: Why No Victim's Advocates On AFA's Investigating Panel?
- May 28, 2003: AFA Cadet Under Investigation Cut From Graduation
- May 14, 2003: Article 32 Hearing Held For Another AFA Cadet
- May 12, 2003: 13-Year-Old Assaulted By AFA Cadet Speaks To 7NEWS
- May 8, 2003: Cadet Testifies In Air Force Academy Sex Case
- May 7, 2003: Cadet, Lawyer, No Shows At Article 32 Hearing
- May 3, 2003: AFA Leadership Reacts To Cadet Operating Porn Site
- May 2, 2003: Conduct Unbecoming: Cadet Allegedly Managing Group Sex Sites On AFA Campus
- May 1, 2003: 7NEWS Investigates: AFA Cadet Operating Sex Sites On Campus
- April 16, 2003: Congressman Draws Fire For Change In AFA Amendment
- April 14, 2003: Congress Approves Independent Investigation Of AFA
- April 14, 2003: Future Cadets Attend Orientation At Air Force Academy
- April 10, 2003: New Command Takes Over At Air Force Academy
- April 9, 2003: AFA Cadets May Face Sex Assault Charges
- April 3, 2003: Senators Approve Independent Inquiry Into AFA Rapes
- April 1, 2003: Senators Blast Air Force Leaders For Not Holding Anyone Accountable
- March 28, 2003: 7NEWS Investigates: AFA Assault Problems Documented For Years
- March 28, 2003: Senior Female AFA Officer To Watch Over Sex Assault Cases
- March 27, 2003: Top AFA Leaders To Be Replaced
- March 26, 2003: Sweeping Changes Proposed At Air Force Academy
- March 24, 2003: Senators Call For Leadership Change At Air Force Academy
- March 21, 2003: More Changes Proposed At Air Force Academy
- March 19, 2003: Report: Top Air Force Academy Officials To Leave
- March 14, 2003: Air Force Has Not Court-Martialed For Cadet-On-Cadet Assaults
- March 12, 2003: Both Teams Of Investigators Now At AFA
- March 11, 2003: Report: Academy Cadets To Be Separated
- March 10, 2003: Bush 'Concerned' About AFA Rape Allegations
- March 10, 2003: Air Force Chief Of Staff: Female Cadets Are Safe Here
- March 6, 2003: Air Force Secretary: 54 Cases Of Rape, Assault, At AFA
- March 5, 2003: Air Force Investigative Team Returns To Springs
- March 4, 2003: Allard Hopes Air Force Investigation Not Just PR Move
- March 1, 2003: Air Force Family Betrayed After Daughter's Rape
- February 28, 2003: More AFA Victims Come Forward As Roche Speaks To Cadets
- February 27, 2003: Secretary Of Air Force Promises Change At AFA
- February 26, 2003: Senators, Chairman Call For Independent AFA Rape Investigation
- February 25, 2003: 3 Senators Ask For Independent Investigation Of AFA Rapes
- February 24, 2003: Air Force Opens Phone Line For Academy Rape Victims
- February 21, 2003: Allard May Ask For Senate Hearing Into AFA Rape Case
- February 20, 2003: 7NEWS Investigates: Air Force Academy's Amnesty Clause
- February 18, 2003: Academy Superintendent Responds To 7NEWS' Rape Investigation
- February 17, 2003: 7NEWS Investigates: Victims Of Academy Rapes Speak Up, Punished
- February 14, 2003: 7NEWS Investigates: Rape Victims At Air Force Academy Afraid To Report
- February 13, 2003: 7NEWS Investigates: Honor, Code, Betrayal At Air Force Academy
- February 11, 2003: 7NEWS Investigates Alleged Rapes At Air Force Academy
Copyright 2007 by TheDenverChannel.com. The Associated Press contributed to this report. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.









