Defense Rests Case In Aaron Thompson Trial
Closing Arguments Scheduled For Friday
POSTED: 11:31 am MDT September 9, 2009
CENTENNIAL, Colo. -- The defense has rested it's case in the trial of an Aurora man charged with fatal child abuse.Aaron Thompson is charged with 60 criminal counts in the disappearance of his daughter, Aarone. The defense wrapped up Wednesday afternoon. Closing arguments are scheduled for Friday with the jury beginning its deliberations on Monday.For a time, it appeared that Thompson would take the stand in his own defense. Thompson asked the judge for time to consider testifying, but eventually declined.
The defense spent Wednesday trying to cast doubt about two statements Thompson allegedly made while in jail this year:“Sometimes you just snap and deal with the consequences.”“It’s easy to hide a body. You just have to bury it deep enough.”After 21 days of testimony from prosecution witnesses, an Arapahoe County Sheriff’s Department staffer took the stand at 8:45 a.m.Nancy Sibak is the housing administrator at the jail, just across the parking lot from the Arapahoe County Justice center where the trial is under way.Sibak identified when convict Jessie Reynolds and Thompson could have been near each other.Reynolds was one of the big surprise witnesses in the prosecution’s parade of adults, children, neighbors, teachers and nuns.He told the jury that in January of this year, he was watching TV with a bunch of other inmates at the jail. Reynolds said one of the inmates was Thompson.A story on a cable news show centered on a missing Florida girl, Caylee Anthony. The girl’s body was found in a trash bag near the home and her mother is suspected of involvement in her death.Reynolds said there was talk about how a parent could allegedly do something like that.At that point, Reynolds testified he heard someone say, “Sometimes you just snap and deal with the consequences.”He said he also heard Thompson say, “It’s easy to hide a body, you just have to bury it deep enough.”Today, defense attorney James Karbach was able to raise new questions about the convict’s testimony.Deputy Matt Miller Wednesday told the jury he is the jailer Reynolds first talked to on Jan. 13, 2009, but he did not recall Reynolds saying he heard Thompson utter the “snap” comment. He also told the jury that while he typed up some notes for himself, believing he would be called to testify some day, he did not write a formal report on the discussion with Reynolds, as he normally would do in a high-profile case.He was asked by defense attorney Karbach why he didn’t print up his own notes and give those to a supervisor.“I didn’t think about it,” Miller said.Miller told the jury that he asked Reynolds to write a witness statement.He said Reynolds did so, writing a one page, handwritten statement that has now been lost.Deputy Stefan Gallegos is the intelligence officer within the jail, charged with passing on information that may aid law enforcement or protect inmates. Gallegos said he did write a report about his conversation with Deputy Miller, but also did not recall Reynolds’ statement about Thompson allegedly saying, “Sometimes you just snap.” Under cross-examination, prosecutor Bob Chappell asked deputy Miller if he was aware that the sheriff’s department had been “looking high and low” for the written statement from Reynolds over the past couple of days.Miller said he was.Reynolds also came back to court Wednesday.Since testifying Aug. 19, he has been involuntarily placed in solitary confinement by the Department of Corrections, Reynolds said, due to media coverage.While he told the jury last month he was testifying in the Thompson trial simply because he was offended by the statements, he also wrote a letter that same day to prosecutor Chappell, asking for money. “There’s no way I will survive mentally, without something to alleviate the boredom,” Reynolds wrote in a letter while asking if he might be eligible for a Crimestoppers reward of $800 for his testimony against Thompson. “I had a radio but that was stolen once they found out I was a snitch.”Reynolds told the jury he wanted to buy a TV and a radio for the cell he now occupies 23 hours a day.“People’s minds start to play with them … You get stupid ideas when you’re in a place like that,” Reynolds said.
Previous Stories:
- September 8, 2009: Judge Refuses To Drop Any Charges Against Thompson
- September 3, 2009: Aarone's DNA Profile Found In 'Punishment Place'
- September 2, 2009: Thompson's Defense Likely To Start Next Week
- September 2, 2009: Prosecution In Thompson Case Could Rest Wednesday
- August 31, 2009: Tears On Witness Stand As Child Testifies In Abuse Case
- August 27, 2009: Child Claims He Was Asked To Help Kill Aarone
- August 26, 2009: Boy: Thompson Held Child By Feet Over Toilet
- August 25, 2009: Youngest Child Testifies Against Thompson Through Closed-Circuit TV
- August 24, 2009: Aarone's Stepsister: We'd Get Whoopin' 'Almost Every Day'
- August 21, 2009: Friend: Thompson Yells At Lowe, 'What Did You Do?'
- August 20, 2009: Taped Conversation: Lowe Thought Aarone Was Abused
- August 19, 2009: Jury Watches 7News Exclusive Interview With Thompson, Lowe
- August 18, 2009: Neighbor Says Thompsons "Reclusive"
- August 17, 2009: Another Child Agrees Story About Aarone Is Just Lies
- August 14, 2009: Police Believe Lowe's Pregnancy Prompted Coverup About Aarone
- August 13, 2009: Lowe's Brother Admits He Was Coached About Aarone
- August 12, 2009: Former Lover Tells Jury Lowe Was 'Baby Killer'
- August 11, 2009: Jury Sees Aaron Thompson's Police Interview
- August 10, 2009: Thompson Trial Juror Stays After Intimidation Complaint
- August 7, 2009: Aaron Thompson: I Lied, But I Didn't Kill Aarone
- August 3, 2009: Father's Trial Begins In Case Of Missing Daughter
- June 18, 2009: Jury To Hear 7News Interview In Child Abuse Trial
- June 15, 2009: Hearing Set For Aaron Thompson In Missing Daughter Case
Copyright 2009 by TheDenverChannel.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
The following are comments from our users. Opinions expressed are neither created nor endorsed by TheDenverChannel.com. By posting a comment you agree to accept our Terms of Use. Comments are moderated by the community. To report an offensive or otherwise inappropriate comment, click the "Flag" link that appears beneath that comment. Comments that are flagged by a set number of users will be automatically removed.






