United Stock Freefalls After Trading Resumes Thursday
Airline's Stock Plunges To Lowest Price In 40 Years
POSTED: 6:04 a.m. MST December 5, 2002
UPDATED: 3:30 p.m. MST December 5, 2002
DENVER -- United Airlines stock lost two-thirds of its
value Thursday amid rampant speculation that the world's
second-largest carrier can do nothing except file for bankruptcy.
The New York Stock Exchange had stopped trading in United parent
UAL Corp.'s shares for most of the morning because of "news that's
pending that could materially affect the trading of the stock,"
NYSE spokesman Ray Pellecchia said.
United's parent, UAL Corp., opened at $3.12 on the New York
Stock Exchange and closed at $1, the lowest level in more than 40
years.
Trading was suspended for most of the morning because of what
the NYSE said was "news that's pending that could materially
affect the trading of the stock." But trading resumed later in the
day with no announcement from United on its next move.
Analysts said the rejection of United's request for $1.8 billion
in federal loan guarantees all but ensures a Chapter 11 bankruptcy
filing. It would be the largest bankruptcy in airline industry
history.
Chief executive Glenn Tilton, following a meeting Thursday with
leaders of the pilots' union that holds the largest single stake in
the airline, declined to say whether United will file for
bankruptcy but said it is not inevitable.
"What we have said is we're going to consider all of our
options and nothing really is a foregone conclusion," Tilton told
Chicago's WLS-TV. He said Wednesday that the airline would continue
to fly whatever choice was made.
But barring a dramatic turn of events, that course will almost
certainly take it into federal bankruptcy court as soon as this
week.
"We believe bankruptcy is inevitable," J.P. Morgan analyst
Jamie Baker wrote in a note to investors Thursday.
"I can't imagine them avoiding it unless someone writes them a
check for $2 billion," said Ray Neidl of Blaylock and Partners.
Cash-starved United has said for months that without government
backing, it couldn't get the $2 billion private loan it needs to
avoid bankruptcy. It faces $920 million in debt payments due next
week, which would wipe out most of its cash.
Further sealing United's fate, its mechanics canceled a vote
scheduled for Thursday on $700 million in wage cuts the carrier
said it needed immediately to stay out of bankruptcy. Union leaders
said the government board's decision had rendered the vote moot.
United's unions blasted the decision by the three-member government panel,
which was created last year to help the financially strapped
airline industry recover after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.
"We were ready to partner with United, the union coalition and
the government to return United Airlines into the nation's premier
carrier," said Tom Buffenbarger, president of the Machinists'
union that represents the 13,000 mechanics and aircraft cleaners
who were to have voted. "Unfortunately, the United States
government walked out on that partnership."
United traces its problems to a decline in passengers because of
the faltering economy and the terrorist attacks, an increase in
competition from smaller discount airlines and failed business
strategies. It has lost more than $4 billion since the middle of
2000 and is on pace for an industry-record loss exceeding $2
billion for the second straight year.
The government board said that despite United's efforts to pare
costs, "the business plan submitted by the company is not
financially sound."
The board said United's plan "does not support the conclusion
that there is a reasonable assurance of repayment and would pose an
unacceptably high risk to U.S. taxpayers."
Tilton didn't say whether the company would file for bankruptcy
or file a revised proposal.
Two of the three board members rejected United's request, while
the third wanted to defer a decision until Dec. 9 to allow United
to submit additional financial information.
"This is not just about costs," said one member, Peter Fisher,
the Treasury Department's undersecretary for domestic finance,
"it's about a business plan that is fundamentally flawed."
In bankruptcy, United's shares would probably become virtually
worthless and it would lose control of its restructuring to a
bankruptcy judge. The airline is 55 percent owned by its employees.
The people who fuel and de-ice airplanes didn't have much to say about the latest developments.
"With (Wednesday's) news it's deafening out here," worker Rich
Pijanowski said.
Still, he said union leaders have been busy talking to management, hopeful that United could meet with the panel and see what further cuts it expected from the airline.
"I think most of our group has gotten past how we got here and are more interested in how to get this thing turning in right direction," he said.
Mechanic Dan Mattingly echoed his concerns, saying it makes no sense for unions to approve cuts, only to have them rejected by the panel later.
"The money is just sitting there and they're not helping the airlines out," said Mattingly, who started the day watching on television how United's stock had nose-dived. Like many other workers he accepted wage cuts and work rule changes for six years in exchange for stock which would be rendered worthless by a bankruptcy.
Some passengers flying United on Wednesday said the government
should help it stay in business.
"We need the competition to keep the fares lower," said
Courtney Burkholder, 31, of Lincoln, Neb., as she walked through
Chicago's O'Hare International Airport. "Generally, it seems
unfair that the airlines suffered for the terrorist attacks."
Only two major airlines, America West and US Airways, have
gotten help from the board. But US Airways still ended up filing
for bankruptcy protection in August.
Analysts say United will emerge from bankruptcy a smaller,
changed airline, assuming it emerges at all.
"If they make peace with labor, they will come out of Chapter
11 stronger than they've ever been," said Darrell Jenkins, head of
George Washington University's Aviation Institute.
Other airlines have survived bankruptcy, including America West
and Continental, which filed for bankruptcy twice.
Additional Resources:
The New York Stock Exchange had stopped trading in United parent
UAL Corp.'s shares for most of the morning because of "news that's
pending that could materially affect the trading of the stock,"
NYSE spokesman Ray Pellecchia said.
United's parent, UAL Corp., opened at $3.12 on the New York
Stock Exchange and closed at $1, the lowest level in more than 40
years.
Trading was suspended for most of the morning because of what
the NYSE said was "news that's pending that could materially
affect the trading of the stock." But trading resumed later in the
day with no announcement from United on its next move.
Analysts said the rejection of United's request for $1.8 billion
in federal loan guarantees all but ensures a Chapter 11 bankruptcy
filing. It would be the largest bankruptcy in airline industry
history.
Chief executive Glenn Tilton, following a meeting Thursday with
leaders of the pilots' union that holds the largest single stake in
the airline, declined to say whether United will file for
bankruptcy but said it is not inevitable.
"What we have said is we're going to consider all of our
options and nothing really is a foregone conclusion," Tilton told
Chicago's WLS-TV. He said Wednesday that the airline would continue
to fly whatever choice was made.
UNITED AIRLINES FACTS |
Previous Stories:
-
December 4, 2002: United's Plea For Loan Guarantee Rejected
- December 4, 2002: United Airlines May Be Fined For Duct-Taped Wings
- December 4, 2002: Frontier Fined For Alleged Violations December 4, 2002: United Slashes Number Of Executives, Pay
- December 3, 2002: United To Lay Off 352 More Pilots
- December 2, 2002: United Mechanics To Vote On Pay Cuts, Again
- December 1, 2002: United, Union Meet Over Wage Concessions
- November 30, 2002: United Airlines Flight Attendants Approve Wage Reductions
- November 29, 2002: Bankruptcy Filing Ever More Likely For United
- November 28, 2002: United Machinists Reject Pay Cut
- November 27, 2002: Political Pressure Mounts For Federal United Airlines Loan
- November 20, 2002: United, Machinist Announce Pay-Cut Deal
- November 14, 2002: United Faces Dec. 2 Debt Deadline
- November 4, 2002: United Pilots Union Agree To Big Pay Cuts
- October 22, 2002: United Cuts 1,250 Jobs
- September 26, 2002: United Unions Submit Proposal For Cutting Costs
- September 2, 2002: United Hires New CEO
- August 29, 2002: United Asks Machinists To Accept 10 Percent Paycut
- March 7, 2002: United Airlines Mechanics Ratify Contract
- February 13, 2002: United Mechanics Reject Contract Offer
- February 6, 2002: DIA In Trouble? Banks Refuse To Back Bonds
- December 13, 2001: United Machinists To Take Strike Vote
Copyright 2002 by TheDenverChannel.com. The Associated Press contributed to this report. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.








